Introducing Idea Screening: test early-stage ideas, fast


Introducing Idea Screening: test early-stage ideas, fast

For most companies, there’s rarely a shortage of ideas. The challenge is making sure the ideas you choose to invest in pay off.

Divya Shroff

May 10, 2022 | 6 min read


Ideas can come from anywhere. They pop up in brainstorming sessions, are presented in boardrooms, and wake us up with their potential in the middle of the night. The issue is not quantity; the real struggle is weeding out the bad ideas from the good before you invest time and resources. 

History shows that’s trickier than it seems. Only 6% of “official” ideas and 14% of promising ideas that reach a development phase become commercial successes.  Most marketing, creative and product teams have experienced the pain of selecting a direction that just doesn’t quite land in the market.

The good news is that research can help solve this problem. Testing ideas early in the process can validate which products and campaigns will ultimately perform with a target audience. The right kind of research can help you both identify winners and continually refine your most promising ideas to keep them on track.

But, how do you insert research without impacting rigid timelines? Can teams afford the cost of reaching niche or targeted audiences? And, do companies have the research expertise to accurately pinpoint which ideas will pay off? 

Early-stage research has been hard to swing both from a timing and cost standpoint. Agencies are slow and expensive and qualitative methods only provide insights from a few people. Existing methodologies often deliver results that are difficult to interpret. These approaches can quickly bog down the most nimble teams and agile development efforts. Add in the challenge of finding enough sample to test each element, and this type of research quickly becomes infeasible. But starting today, teams have a new way to launch this type of research without disrupting or delaying the process.

Idea Screening:  Uncover winning ideas, fast

Idea Screening is a new way of validating multiple concepts early in the development cycle; it’s also the fastest way to determine how early-stage ideas will perform with your target audience. With Idea Screening, companies can test up to 20 ideas in a single study and quickly get results in a presentation-ready format; sometimes in as little as an hour.

It’s ideal for product development, marketing and creative teams, where ideas go from concept to completion on a predetermined path. Inserting Idea Screening early in the concepting stage can ultimately save teams time on revisions and redos later in the process, when changes are costly and disruptive.

Idea screening is complementary to Concept Testing, which is designed for more specific testing once ideas are more fully developed. Concept testing would be used to vet elements like packaging, logos, ads or messaging later in  the process.

A cost-effective, speedy research approach

Idea Screening is based on the sequential monadic methodology; a proven approach that requires less sample than other methods. It allows you to test multiple ideas in any format—text, video, or image—all in the same study. 

For example, let’s say you needed to vet 10 different campaign ideas, with a goal of narrowing it down to the top three concepts that would ultimately become fully produced ads. With a monadic study, you’d need 200 responses for each of the 10 concepts, for a total of 2000 responses.

With sequential monadic, each respondent would see a subset of 4 ads, so you would only need a sample size of 500 hundred to get 200 responses per add. That’s a big savings in terms of panel costs, and a much faster study to field.

Research methodologies

Recently, we worked with a major CPG client that produced 20 rough, animated cuts of commercials for a TV campaign. They all highlighted different benefits and even used several different actors. They were overwhelmed with options and needed to decide on the one commercial to send into the networks.

They did some sequential monadic testing with us to screen the ideas and narrow it down to the top five, which were fully produced by their agency and moved to the next stage of research, copy testing.

At the time, we didn’t have the purpose-built solution so creating a scorecard that summarized all 20 cuts was a pretty taxing, manual process. Even then, you can imagine how much they saved in production costs by getting a quick check early on. Now, with our idea screening solution, conducting this type of early research would be exponentially faster, more cost-effective, and would automatically uncover the most important insights. 

Get your study up and running quickly

Delaying a product or creative project with a research cycle is a hard sell for most teams. That’s why we’ve made it fast and easy to launch a study without disrupting the development or creative process. 

You can deploy a study in a matter of hours and collect results in as little as an hour. Using our guided self-service setup and a default study design, will give you a leg up. Select from a standard set of attributes, such as Overall appeal, Believable, Unique, Meets your needs, or Purchase Intent, or add custom attributes to test multiple stimuli.

Finding the right sample is easy, even for niche or hard to reach audiences, using our integrated panel. Tap into 175M+ people in 130+ countries including B2B or B2C audiences.

Harness AI insights and automated analysis

Once  you launch a  study is typically where the work begins. Analyzing results that include multiple stimuli, attributes and audiences can be an overwhelming task, especially for fast- moving projects or for teams that don’t have deep research expertise.

This is when Idea Screening does the heavy lifting. It surfaces the actionable insights in your data, leveraging our AI-based methodology and eliminating manual data filtering and analysis.

Insights are delivered in easy-to-read scorecards that highlight statistically significant results. You’ll see at-a-glance how your ideas stack up based on your chosen attributes. Dive deeper into the data with a unique algorithm that analyzes your results against hundreds of demographic combinations so you can quickly see which ideas each demographic segment preferred.

Packaging Idea Screening2X

Word clouds, crosstab reports, filters, and presentation-ready deliverables offer users both high-level and detailed insights even with a limited sample size.

But, will they buy it?

The ultimate test of any product or marketing initiative is if it sells, literally or conceptually. That’s why we built in Key Driver Analysis, which clearly indicates which attributes will actually drive purchase so you know what to invest in and what won’t move the needle. This helps to identify areas of opportunity and improvement, and gives you confidence that the products, creative, and campaigns you build will make a greater impact. 

Get started testing your ideas

Whether you’re just starting a new project or in the middle of it, its not to late to research your top ideas. We have developed a family of market research solutions to meet the needs of marketing, product development and insights teams at all stages of the development process.

Learn more about Idea Screening, or talk to a Momentive research expert about your next project.

Read more articles by Momentive

Stay up to date on the trends that are reshaping industries, the innovations that are bringing humanity and technology closer together, and more.


Momentive study: US+APAC Gen Z shopping habits

According to a Van Westendorp pricing sensitivity analysis, $90 is the optimal price of special-edition sneakers among US Gen Zers, with acceptable pricing ranging between $60 to $130.

Mar 17 • 4 min read

Read more


How Pie Insurance centralized survey data with Momentive

Learn how Pie Insurance turned to SurveyMonkey Enterprise by Momentive to standardize survey collection and further safeguard customer data.

Nov 29 • 3 min read

Read more